Skip navigation

Published July 11, 2021

| 6 Comments | Leave A Reply


Don Yoder—the late, great godfather of many things Pennsylvania Dutch—pretty much started the academic study of ethnic folklore.

Which he expanded to include the terms “folklife” and “folkways.”

Which led to a term that I like a lot, “foodways,” since I’m definitely someone for who the path to my heart runs through my stomach.

I know I’ve touched on various elements of my food heritage in past “Roots & Branches” columns but what I’m struck by how many of these culinary memories are tied to particular people, mostly the only three ancestors of whom I have firm memories—my mother, my father and my “Gramom,” who was my father’s mother.

Let’s start with “Gramom,” who was Dora Annie Etchberger Beidler and lived with my family part time for four years and then full time for nine years.

My top memory is that chicken pot pie was her domain—starting with hand rolling the dough for noodles to the finished product—and my mother stayed out of the way.

Another of her specialties was one that my dad loved but that would literally almost make me vomit. It was a breakfast dish called “pudding” and I never got near waning to find out what was in it, other than a multitude of onions. Usually this was made on Saturday mornings when I would have rather slept in … but the smell of this got me out of bed and house in a hurry.

As far as my dad, Richard Lee Beidler, he was a classic male of his time—pretty much only doing the grill cooking. My chief memories of this is that he made his steaks more than well done … and then salted the bejesus out of them. In reaction to that, I’m inclined to take my steak medium or medium rare and never add salt (to anything!).

But he did also shine in putting together a feast of steamed clams every year as a celebration of harvesting hundreds of ears of sweet corn from his quarter-acre garden. On this score, we were in total agreement … no at-home meal is better, to my mind, than corn and clams!

But my mother, Mildred Mae Hiester Beidler, was the chief cook and I think about how much I must have tried her patience as an extremely finicky eater as a child (I started getting over that in college and it’s made keeping a decent waistline a challenge!).

My favorite food as a child, whether eating in or out, was fried chicken, particularly breasts and wings. My dad liked gizzards, too, but I only developed a taste for them in Birmingham, Alabama, where supermarket delis had them available by the pint.

Now that’s one of my favorite meals and fortunately my girlfriend, Terri J. Bridgwater, is willing to indulge me even though she doesn’t personally like them.

Foodways endure!

6 Comments

  1. toni

    3 years ago  

    chicken pot pie was her domain—starting with hand rolling the dough for noodles to the finished product— Do you have a recollection memory of what was in this dish? Did she use noodles in the pie?


    • 3 years ago  

      … she used what I would call “dough squares” – thicker than what I’d call noodles and square (or rectangular) in shape …


  2. Janet Rupert

    3 years ago  

    Pot pie was one of my favorites, and I regularly make it for my grandchildren, using my mother-in-law’s recipe (basically eggs, water, and flour; roll it out and cut in squares, although sometimes we get creative and use animal cookie cutters for “barnyard potpie”). Ma was “Dutch” to the core (as was my father-in-law). I also make her “Dutch cakes” (a potato bread which is sweet and great for breakfast or sticky buns). Hmm, all those Dutchy things seem to be heavy on the carbs and calories, but oh, so good. Food is definitely a key way of connecting to our ethnic heritage and passing on family traditions. Great memories.


    • 3 years ago  

      I love the idea of “barnyard pot pie!” And, yes, there are no low cal PA Dutch recipes! LOL! I’ve written about it before – one of my most treasured keepsakes is a recipe (for “Lemon Custard with Cake Topping”) in my grandmother’s own hand that she sent to a relative – and then a descendant of that relative many years later sent it on to me!


  3. B Snyder

    3 years ago  

    I am Pa Dutch and Swiss German. We always had homemade chicken pot pie. You can get it in many mom and pop restaurants in Adams County, Pa. I didn’t know it was different in the rest of the country til I moved to Colorado. I have since learned many people call it slippery pot pie. Not sure if this is a common name. That stuff you get in a pie crust is definitely NOT pot pie. LOL. I wonder if anyone has a good recipe for it. My mother left me many recipes but not that one. My grandfather and all his family spoke Pennsyvania Dutch. He died when I was only 17 and never had the chance to ask him about his German ancestry. I was too young and didn’t know what genealogy was. Luckily I did take 2 years of Gsrman in Junior high and an read some German and speak some.
    My neighbors a few doors away were Beidlers in Biglerville ,Pa.


    • 3 years ago  

      I’m sure there are pot pie recipes around although I think folks such as my gramom probably just worked from memory handed down to her! And when you talk about moving away and finding out different food customs – I went to a summer orientation before college at Hofstra on Long Island – had some time to kill before taking a train back into NYC so I went to the nearby diner and decided to have a “Steak Sandwich.” It was culture shock when I a ribeye on toast came out!